| Ian Abplanalp
| 5-6 | 125 | Fr.
| Grove City, Pa. / Grove City |
| Dan Barzelatto
| 6-0 | 197 | Fr.
| Tenafly, N.J. / Tenafly |
| Michael Baxter
| 5-5 | 133 | Jr.
| Sandusky, Ohio / Perkins |
| Robert Blotzer
| 5-6 | 141 | So.
| McKeesport, Pa. / South Allegheny |
| Ryan Bohince
| 5-7 | 125 | Fr.
| Level Green, Pa. / Penn Trafford |
| Pat Carter
| 5-11 | 174 | Jr.
| North Java, N.Y. / Attica |
| Londele Cox
| 5-10 | 184 | Fr.
| Pittsburgh, Pa. / |
| Tony D'Urso
| 5-8 | 141 | So.
| Greenville, Pa. / Renyolds |
| Shane Foster
| 5-8 | 149 | Fr.
| Dalton, Ohio / Massillon Perry |
| Eric Fulmer
| 5-9 | 184 | Jr.
| Pittsburgh, Pa. / Shaler Area |
| Ian Grecco
| 6-0 | 141 | Fr.
| Brockway, Pa. / Brockway |
| Fred Hale
| 6-2 | 285 | Jr.
| Mentor, Ohio / Mentor |
| Nick Hannan
| 5-6 | 150 | Fr.
| Bolivar, Ohio / Massillon Perry |
| Patrick Leahy
| 5-9 | 174 | Jr.
| Broadview Heights, Ohio / Brecksville-Broadview Heights |
| Eric Lundgren
| 6-1 | 197 | Fr.
| DuBois, Pa. / DuBois Area |
| Chris McAndrew
| 6-0 | 197 | Jr.
| Harborcreek, Pa. / Harbor Creek |
| Tim McAndrew
| 5-7 | 174 | Jr.
| Erie, Pa. / Harbor Creek |
| Lance Pitcel
| 5-10 | 141 | Sr.
| Casco, Mich. / Richmond |
| Jeffrey Pollard
| 6-5 | 285 | Jr.
| Fairview, Pa. / Fairview High School |
| Michael Pollard
| 6-1 | 195 | Fr.
| Corry, Pa. / Corry |
| Austin Roland
| 6-0 | 165 | Fr.
| Fairport, N.Y. / Fairport |
| Clint Schaefer
| 5-11 | 157 | So.
| Lancaster, N.Y. / Lancaster |
| Nathan Sharp
| 6-2 | 285 | Sr.
| Beloit, Ohio / West Branch |
| Chaz Sheaffer
| | 184 | Fr.
| |
| Jordan Shields
| 5-6 | 149 | Fr.
| Burrell, Pa. / Burrell |
| Josh Shields
| 6-0 | 165 | Sr.
| Burrell, Pa. / Burrell |
| Levi Smeltzer
| 5-7 | 141 | Jr.
| Elderton, Pa. / Elderton |
| T.J. Stanton
| | 125 | Fr.
| Dubois, Pa. / Dubois |
| Seth Stonis
| 6-0 | 174 | So.
| Edinboro, Pa. / General McLane |